Syrian Lesbian Bloggers, Fake Geishas, and the Attractions of Identity Tourism by Lisa Nakamura
"MacMaster and Graber learned first-hand that appropriating lesbian identities would give them readers and afford them entry to a close-knit community that they could never hope to penetrate in real life. Even better, they could become a part of this community without having to endure the humiliations and inconvenience that real lesbians must face. Amina’s bravery as an 'out' lesbian in a repressive political regime drew readers and journalists who were eager for inspiring stories of queer women of color. And MacMaster’s cowardice and need for respect and attention made it impossible for him to stop creating these stories."
Hmm, is it safe to post an article rationalizing the faking of lesbian identity yet? LOL I know there were a few whose emotions ran high back in June, when this story first broke out. I found Nakamura's use of Gayatri Spivak, Edward Said, and her own coining of "identity tourism" (where claiming to be part of the Other gains one more cultural capital) to be quite interesting.
(I saw this article while glancing at
colorblue's recent rec of Grace Wang's On Tiger Mothers & Music Moms and thought it would be interesting to share.)
"MacMaster and Graber learned first-hand that appropriating lesbian identities would give them readers and afford them entry to a close-knit community that they could never hope to penetrate in real life. Even better, they could become a part of this community without having to endure the humiliations and inconvenience that real lesbians must face. Amina’s bravery as an 'out' lesbian in a repressive political regime drew readers and journalists who were eager for inspiring stories of queer women of color. And MacMaster’s cowardice and need for respect and attention made it impossible for him to stop creating these stories."
Hmm, is it safe to post an article rationalizing the faking of lesbian identity yet? LOL I know there were a few whose emotions ran high back in June, when this story first broke out. I found Nakamura's use of Gayatri Spivak, Edward Said, and her own coining of "identity tourism" (where claiming to be part of the Other gains one more cultural capital) to be quite interesting.
(I saw this article while glancing at
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)